Oddly enough, sin is generally something you do rather than

canada goose coats on sale you hate the believer Why Evolution Is True canada goose coats on sale

canada goose coats Andrew Brown: If you canada goose parka outlet uk hate the belief, you hate the believerI suppose there a good case to be made for ignoring the Guardian Official Clickbait Troll, Andrew Brown. After all, his views are completely predictable, and his commenters usually give him the good hiding he deserves. But occasionally he goes so far beyond the pale that even Professor Ceiling Cat must give him a few scratches. And so it is with Brown piece at the Guardian. by a photograph of canada goose outlet price Sam Harris, Brown thesis is simple: if you goose outlet canada hate an ideology or a belief, you must perforce hate the person who canada goose outlet usa holds it. This is, of course, hisway of accusing canada goose outlet in canada the New Atheists of lying: we really all religion canada goose outlet and canada goose factory outlet Muslim haters. Or, as he says:Some people who claim that Islam is profoundly evil will also say that they bear Muslims no ill will but I don’t think they are canada goose outlet jackets telling the truth. It is really difficult and indeed psychologically unnatural to claim that you hate an ideology canada goose uk without hating the people in whose lives it is expressed. Religions, nations, and even races are all shared imaginative constructs (although nations and races have other characteristics as well) and if you really want to extirpate them, you must extirpate the people who imagine them as well.This is completely insane. I have several friends who are religious (in fact, some of my closest friends), and they know I am an atheist. I find their religious beliefs insupportable, and I sure they know that. But they are lovely people, and I don consider a liberal form of belief to be something that should dissolve a friendship that has so many greater benefits. Likewise, not all Muslims embrace the extreme, misogynistic, and hateful forms of the faith, and I know at least one Muslim whom I see as a friend, and many others whom I do not hate.Yes, it true that if someone holds really hateful views, like extreme prejudice against gays and blacks, it would be hard not to dislike canada goose discount uk them, but there are many beliefs I find distasteful that aren cause for personal hatred. After all, don most of our friends hold canada goose outlet uk fake at least one view that we dislike, even intensely? Religion, to me, is a pretty big deal, but there are plenty of liberal religionists whom I don hate, but nevertheless would attack their beliefs on my site (not necessarily in their faces!) with everything I have.Brown also canada goose outlet in usa believes that there is no difference between hating someone for their beliefs or canada goose outlet vip their race.It is a trope among people who loathe and fear Islam that their fear and loathing has nothing in common with racism because Islam is not a race, the implication being that hating Muslims is rational and wise whereas hating black people is deeply irrational and stupid.Here he conflates again and fearing Islam and Muslims Those aren the same thing depending on the Muslim. It really depends on now much of their personality is composed of the stuff I don like, and of what kind of stuff that I don like.That is not the same as hating black people, for that truly is irrational: the only thing that unites them (besides being marginalized in white societies) canada goose outlet mississauga is the color of their skin. Skin color is not a cause of malfeasance. Religious belief often is a cause of malfeasance. You cannot change your skin color, even if someone tells you that you should be white. You can change your religious belief (granted, it determined by the laws of physics whether you do that or not), butif you continue to hold onto bad beliefs after being corrected, you can then be publiclyexcoriated for beliefs that are harmful for society. Skin color is not harmful to society, and society hasnothing to gain (and much to lose) by excoriating someone for being black.AsMichael Stipe said, no, I said too much. Brown doesn really deserve our attention, as I don think he has much influence. But his dullness helps us sharpen our own minds. Let me canada goose outlet phone number finish with Brown ending, in which he profoundly misquotes (and misunderstands) what Sam Harris said, something Harris has explained already on his own site,and which Brown might have read before spouting these inanities.But if we allow that the http://www.mycanadagoosejacket.org crimes of Stalin, or of Mao, were comparable to those of the transatlantic slave trade in ambition if not in duration, they are not excused in the slightest by saying that the most terrible atheist dictators were not very racist at all.Stalin and Mao would have enthusiastically endorsed Sam Harris when he wrote that „there are some beliefs so terrible that we are justified in killing people just for holding them“, just as they would have endorsed his defence of torturing prisoners.In the end, the position of people who claim that hatred of Islam is somehow superior to hatred of black people is pretty much like Alan Partridge boasting that at least he’s not David Brent.But what, in the end, is Brown message? That we should lay off criticizing any beliefs because that the same as criticizing the believer? (Has Brown suddenly turned Muslim?) In fact, canada goose outlet store quebec I don know what Brown message is, except this: found hypocrisy in the New Atheists. And that about as profound as the man ever gets.Oddly enough, sin is generally something you do rather than something you believe. So the sin, but love the sinner instructs us to love people who behave badly.But Islam did not invent the concepts of heresy and canada goose outlet in vancouver apostasy. The idea that unbelievers and wrong believers were to be shunned or treated as enemies was already old when Islam was new.Profession of faith is a tribal shibboleth, a non physical circumcision, that identifies you as canada goose parka outlet a friend or enemy. I suspect that really why faith persists.are just bigoted, raging, scumbag homophobes? kinda. Presumably those Catholics don personally feel antipathy toward homosexuals, but they do support laws and policies which canada goose outlet parka discriminate against homosexuals, and that exactly why homophobia is bad in canada goose outlet washington dc the first place. So the sin, love the sinner canada goose outlet los angeles fails as a defense to a charge of religious homophobia.Does that mean the corresponding argument ( the religion, not the religious fails as a defense to a charge of Islamophobia? That depends. Does Sam Harris, for example, support laws or policies which discriminate against Muslims? I would say no (though many would say yes, and I think it an arguable point). So the thing that makes Islamophobia bad canada goose outlet toronto factory in the first place (support for anti Muslim discrimination) does not apply to Sam criticisms of Islam. But it does apply to anyone who wants to ban all immigration from Muslim countries, for example.It important that we continue to make the argument that criticism of Islam is not the same as Islamophobia, but when we do so, we should take pains to identify real Islamophobia in order to highlight the difference. Many critics of Islam really are Islamophobes, so those of us who are not should try to teach others how to tell us apart.I don think he thinks canada goose outlet store calgary that, but he wants people to believe that Sam Harris thinks that. I thought Sam was saying Islam motivated Islamist extremists, and that killing extremists is valid; if Sam conclusion is that all Muslims must die I guess I missed that part.Interesting that canada goose outlet location he throws in as a snarky aside an actual canada goose clothing uk person GW Bush whose orders resulted in the actual killing of actual people including canada goose outlet woodbury non combatants. The only intelligent thing I ever heard from Bush was his emphatic distinction of Muslims vs. extremists and terrorists, and he made that point many times in speeches. The Iraq war was a disaster launched on false pretenses, but maintaining it was not a war on Islam was smart politics and, I think, true.Everybody makes some distinction between ideas and the people who hold them; not doing so is the thing that unnatural.There was a BBC satire news programme during the reign of Bush II (Second of that Line) in America that gave the true reason for the Second Iraq War. They did it in a song in the Rogers and Cowboy school and titled was Mean to Mah Pappy! So, actually, I do agree that for Bush II, it wasn really a war on Islam. Bush II wasn of course, the only actor involved, just the figurehead. There to attract flack and take the bullets that should be aimed at the real puppet masters.Does he go on to explain what the hell he means by construct and how the parenthetical in that quote does not invalidate his comparison? What does he mean by characteristics if not to canada goose outlet online uk point out that nationality and race are features of persons that are more than just in their head?Regardless, he admits that religion lacks those characteristics Does he really think that genocide is the only way to rid the world of a false idea? What does Brown think the good of writing essays is, if not to change people minds canada goose coats.

Schreib einen Kommentar

Deine E-Mail-Adresse wird nicht veröffentlicht. Erforderliche Felder sind markiert *